NEW
MEDIA AND THE MARKETING STRATEGIES OF NIGERIAN BANKS: A CASE STUDY OF FIRST
BANK OF NIGERIA LTD
ADELOLA ADEROGBAYIMIKA ADEYEMIM.Sc., PGGE, ANIPR., GMNIM.
National Open
University of Nigeria, Lagos.
University of
Lapland, Rovaniemi, Finland.
ABSTRACT
The objective of this article is to examine if new media marketing concept
as a new business philosophy has been effectively adopted in the banking
industry. The study is based on the information gathered and collected from
both primary and secondary sources. The sample for the study is drawn from the
First Bank of Nigeria. Data analysis for the study was carried out using
chi-square method of data analysis.
Findings
of the study revealed that marketing activities have been playing a dominant
role in the developmental effort of the financial sector of the economy.
Therefore, the continued existence of the industry and the development of the
Nigerian economy will depend on its ability to design and map out appropriate
and creative marketing strategy that take cognizance of the new media.
Consequently, how soon these organisations embrace the realities of these
new media in Nigeria goes a long way in determining the extent to which they
experience the benefits of new media marketing.
Keywords: New Media, Marketing, Nigerian banks, Internet, Social
media, Facebook, Twitter
INTRODUCTION
In the 21st
century, the face of marketing has dramatically changed as new media channels
are surfacing all the time, the
last fifteen years have witnessed the rise of new media channels such as iPads,
iPods, Blackberries,
Mobile televisions, Mobile phones, Facebook, YouTube, Google, Twitter, et
cetera and these new media have not only threatened long
established business models of marketing and corporate communication
strategies, but also provide ample opportunities for growth. Through new adaptive strategies,
businesses are finally giving in to new media largely promoted by the internet
with an option so interactive, economical, and convenient (Belch & Belch, 2004).
The advent of
mobile television, mobile phones, and the internet, which enable customers to take a more active role
as market players and reach (and be reached by) almost everyone anywhere and
anytime has led to the belief that the
traditional means of information dissemination will be a thing of the past.
With viewers now “multi-tasking”-using more than one medium at once-surfing the
internet while watching television (Belch &
Belch, 2004).
Consequently,
technology has empowered consumers to control their own streams of information,
entertainment, and content; where and when they want them. Therefore, media
planning in “this” future will have to change dramatically to keep up (Belch & Belch, 2004).
Specifically,
across the banking world, the pace of change is rapidly accelerating and
business models are quickly evolving. Survival in this brave new world is no
longer based on the size of the bank, but rather on its ability to innovate.
Most banks are investing heavily in applications for smart phones and digital
tablets that make it easy for customers to conduct a wide range of banking
activities while on the go. Some are developing interactive tools that help
customers analyze their spending habits and strengthen their money management
skills. Still others are mobilizing the power of social networks to draw “fans”
to feature-rich Facebook pages that build their brands and entice consumers to
share personal information.
Consequently, each
of these initiatives marks a major effort to harness fast-moving digital
technologies, unrestricted mobile access and vibrant social media to boost the
banks’ interactions with their customers. But to a large degree the digital
pioneers-as well as banks that have yet to cross the digital Rubicon-are also
in a battle for survival as they race to keep up with consumers’ rapid embrace
of wireless interconnectivity.
Agboola
& Ologunde, (2009); noted that the revolution has
changed the way of banking such that though money is still being handled,
information, not money is now the life blood of the banking industry. They further claimed that in the new culture,
a bank is defined almost solely by its ability to add value to the customers’
relationship, which breaks down into acquiring, analyzing, integrating, and
leveraging of information about, from and for the benefit of each individual
customer.
For instance,
First Bank of Nigeria Plc, a leading Nigeria financial services institution by
total assets and gross earnings with more than five million customers, over 695
branches and eleven subsidiary companies in Nigeria, providing a comprehensive
range of financial services recently announced that it will shut down
operations from Thursday June 6, and reopen on Monday June 10, 2013 in order to
upgrade its core banking application to Finacle 10 from Finacle 7, so as to
ensure better and faster customer transaction. This move will affect millions
of the bank’s customers, with over 700 branches nationwide.
In order to
achieve its objective without losing too many customers the bank deployed the
marketing communication strategy of communicating with the customer through
diverse media; Social network media-Facebook & Twitter, Phone-SMS
notification and instant messages on blackberries, YouTube, flyers, banners and
e-mail etc of the development and apologized for inconveniences that they might
suffer as a result of the platform upgrade.
Although the bank
had the option of closing up shop for a week and pray that the customers would
still remain at the end of the upgrade, however, it chose to adopt the
strategically coordinated marketing communication activities to garner the
understanding, patience, and support of its customers.
A careful scrutiny
of the media vehicles used by the bank revealed that majority of the media used
to communicate the upgrade was tilted in favour of the new media. Moreover, studies
have shown that Nigerian banks are now embracing and finding it easier to
market their product and services via the new media vehicles. Albeit, it has
been observed that most customers are not satisfied with the service rendered
by the banks and find it difficult to embrace this innovation. While the banks
are yet to effectively master the art of new media marketing in order to
control the long line of customers seen in Nigerian banks. Therefore, this
research will attempt to answer the question; “To what extent has the
management of corporate organisations’ effectively utilise new media in their
marketing activities?” This
study will therefore attempt to test the following hypotheses:
·
There is no significant
relationship between consumers’ embrace of new media technology and its impact
on the services rendered by First Bank of Nigeria.
·
There is no relationship
between First Bank management’s adoption of new media and the effective
utilisation in its marketing strategies.
Þ
INDEPENDENT
VARIABLE: The independent variable here is the
demographic and psychographic grouping of the consumers which will determine
the customers’ embrace of new media which is meant to impact on the adoption of
the new media in the marketing strategies of Nigerian banks.
Þ DEPENDENT VARIABLE: While
the dependent variable is the operational and marketing strategies the Nigerian
banks. Nigerian Banks are supposed to respond to the increase in consumers’
adoption of new media by introducing new media compliant operational and
marketing strategies. This is what this research is determined to find out.
NEW
MEDIA AND THE NIGERIAN BANKING INDUSTRY
A bank is a financial intermediary that accepts
deposits and channels those into lending activities, either directly or through
capital market. A bank connects customers with capital deficits and capital
surpluses Goldwaith, (1995) in (www.15projects.com).
Banking industries is generally a highly regulated
industry, and government restrictions on financial activities by banks have
varied overtime and location. Thus we have various types of banks as dictated
by individual countries’ economic polices such as:
(1)
Central banks
(2)
Commercial banks
(3)
Community Development
banks
(4)
Micro-finance banks
(5)
Investment banks
(6)
Industrial development
banks
(7)
Merchant banks
(8)
Savings and loans banks
Banks act as a payment agent by conducting checking or
current account for customers, paying cheques drawn by customers on the bank,
and collecting cheques deposited to customers.
According
to Cochin, (2000); the banking Industry is one of the most important
service industries which touches the lives of millions of people. Its service
is unique both in social and economic points of view of a nation. Earlier the
attitude of banking service was that it was not professional to sell one's
services and was unnecessary in the sense that traditional relationships and
quality of products were sufficient to carry forward the tasks. Before the mid
1950's the banks had no understanding or regard for marketing. The bank
building was created in the image of a Greek Temple to impress the public about
the importance of a bank. The interior was austere and the teller rarely
smiled. Bankers maintained austere dignity and they hardly maintained
friendliness.
It
was in the late 1950's that marketing in banking industry emerged in the west.
It emergence was in the form of advertising and promotion concept. At that
time, personal selling could not get a significant place. Gradually there was a
change in the attitude of bankers, probably in tune with the attitudinal change
in customers. The idea of customers' satisfaction began in the late 1950's,
flourished in 1960's and became an integral part of the banking services in the
1970's (Cochin, 2000).
According to Vater, Cho, & Sidebottom, (2012);
something big is stirring in retail banking. Across the
world, financial institutions are rolling out a broad array of initiatives that
place bold bets on new digital technologies, which they expect will
fundamentally change how they attract and retain customers. Most banks are investing heavily in
applications for smartphones and digital tablets that make it easy for
customers to conduct a wide range of banking activities while on the go. Some are
developing interactive tools that help customers analyze their spending habits
and strengthen their money management skills. Still others are mobilizing the
power of social networks to draw “fans” to feature-rich Facebook pages that
build their brands and entice consumers to share personal information. Each of
these initiatives marks a major effort to harness fast-moving digital
technologies, unrestricted mobile access and vibrant social media to banks’
interactions with their customers. But to a large degree the digital
pioneers-as well as banks that have yet to cross the digital Rubicon-are also
in a battle for survival as they race to keep up with consumers’ rapid embrace
of wireless interconnectivity.
A growing number
of banks are now looking to new media and the social media to drive customer
acquisition and loyalty. Incorporating these media into product definition,
competitive positioning and customer experience management may have a
pronounced impact on a bank’s growth trajectory. Viewing new media as an
opportunity for real-time discussions and research with customers gives
marketers a powerful tool that most banks have yet to take full advantage of.
And increasingly, this is focused on the integration of new and social media
into the customer profile, analyzing the data to provide actionable insights
and then utilizing these insights to create a truly holistic digital strategy Alton Adams in (Jordaan, M., 2012).
The
Nigerian banking industry is one of the most dynamic and competitive industries
in the Country. The banking industry has transformed rapidly in the last ten
years, shifting from transactional and customer service-oriented to an
increasingly aggressive environment in which competition for revenue is top
priority.
The Nigerian Bank can now fit into the global definition of a bank. Consolidation of the Nigerian Banking sector is one of many reforms of the Gen. Obasanjo's administration that Nigerians have to embrace happily (Victor E, 2007) in (www.StudyMode.com, 2009). Prior to the reforms, the industry was highly fragmented, with many banks having very small and undiversified capitalization. With a much higher capitalization base, the Nigerian banking sector will be expected to play an important role in financing economic development through increased credit to the private sector Soludo, (2008) cited in (www.StudyMode.com, 2009).
The Nigerian Bank can now fit into the global definition of a bank. Consolidation of the Nigerian Banking sector is one of many reforms of the Gen. Obasanjo's administration that Nigerians have to embrace happily (Victor E, 2007) in (www.StudyMode.com, 2009). Prior to the reforms, the industry was highly fragmented, with many banks having very small and undiversified capitalization. With a much higher capitalization base, the Nigerian banking sector will be expected to play an important role in financing economic development through increased credit to the private sector Soludo, (2008) cited in (www.StudyMode.com, 2009).
The Nigerian banking system
has undergone remarkable changes over the years, in terms of the number of
institutions, ownership structure, as well as depth and breadth of operations.
These changes have been influenced largely by challenges posed by deregulation
of the financial sector, globalization of operations, technological innovations
and adoption of supervisory and prudential requirements that conform to
international standards.
Prior to the recent reforms,
the state of the Nigerian banking sector was very weak. According to Soludo
(2004); ‘‘The Nigerian banking system today is fragile and marginal. The system
faces enormous challenges which, if not addressed urgently, could snowball into
a crisis in the near future. He identified the problems of the banks,
especially those seen as feeble, as persistent illiquidity, unprofitable
operations and having a poor assets base’’ (Adegbaju
& Olokoyo, 2008).
Competition was more or less unknown in the immediate
past banking era, there was little or no need for marketing strategy which
include, innovation, product development, public relation, promotion, and
marketing research. The banks then concentrated mainly on advertising as their
only marketing strategy.
The trend in the banking industry in recent times
provides an interesting example of a service industry that has in the past paid
very little attention to the development of strategic marketing for marketing
banking services (Olujide & Aremu, 2009).
However, the situation is changing now with the gradual re-emergence of the
Nigerian middle class which has given rise to a class of knowledgeable and
financially savvy customers. Their benchmarks for service quality have also
risen, aided by the intense competition among financial service providers to
attract new customers. It is no longer just sufficient to provide products, but
to align these closely with specific customer segments and their identified
expectations. In response to the demands for quick, efficient and reliable
services, industry players are increasingly deploying digital technology as a
means of generating insights into customers’ behavioural patterns and
preferences and satisfying them (Oluwagbemi, Abah, & Achimugu, 2011).
New media marketing strategy is increasingly being
adopted in virtually all the sectors of the economy, particularly the service
sector. Marketing strategy has been a major determinant of any organization's
short run and long run success and differential advantage in any marketing
environment. The need for new media marketing strategy in any organization
cannot be over emphasized, this strategy is particularly important in the
banking industry in Nigeria today because of the volatility, highly competitive
and the turbulent nature of the marketing environment. Therefore, each of the
banking institutions must use marketing strategy to develop a competitive
advantage (Olujide & Aremu, 2009).
The role of new media marketing strategy in the
banking sector is to assist in proffering alternative solutions to the problems
encountered in the marketing of their services. Thus, the success and
differential advantages in marketing of banking services could be attained when
an organization can determine the needs and wants of the customer and directs
its marketing effort towards those needs and wants in creative and personalized
manner.
Bulut & Mandaric, (2012); argues that marketers’ perceptions of marketing in
a new communication era have changed with the market expansion of companies…
concludes that, regardless of the dominant focus of marketing within an
organisation, marketing practitioners increasingly have a new media requirement
within their marketing practice.
Bulut & Mandaric, (2012 );
recommended a reflection on the
changing nature of marketing and companies’ new priorities in their marketing
strategies and tactics in order to achieve a better position on the market and
therefore advances that the understanding of new and social media marketing can
improve their relationships with customers and their business process.
ROLE OF NEW
MEDIA IN THE BANKING INDUSTRY
New media is important because it helps marketers keep
up with the times and understand how consumers and the world communicate. It is
a way for marketers to connect and share ideas with consumers in their own
element.
The role of new media marketing strategy in the
banking sector is to assist in proffering alternative solutions to the problems
encountered in the marketing of their services. Thus, the success and
differential advantages in marketing of banking services could be attained when
an organisation can determine the needs and wants of the customer and directs
its marketing effort towards those needs and wants in creative and personalized
manner (Bulut & Mandaric, 2012 ).
New media creates the opportunity for a business to be
taken to a whole new level. For instance, web video is a new way for businesses
to communicate with customers in a more emotional environment. Combining the
use of audio and visual effects on the web, can be a much more memorable
experience for customers, and have much more of an impact. Using online video
advertising allows businesses to bypass the high costs of producing television
commercials; it has been found that consumers are typically more likely to
respond better to online video advertisements rather than image advertisements.
Studies have shown that video advert click rates are far higher than image
adverts.
By making a video available online, the amount of
circulation it receives can end up driving a large amount of traffic to a
company website, or store. Studies have shown that after viewing an online
video for a company, fourteen percent of viewers visit the company store and
eight percent make an actual purchase.
Web videos are beneficial to a business because they
are constantly available. Anyone with the access to a computer or wireless
device can instantly have access to whatever they wish. Businesses are also
able to change any details online almost instantaneously. Any updates or breaking
news that a company wishes to discuss can be changed or added within seconds (Rogers, 2007).
The digital marketing technology which allows
businesses to view what type of customers are purchasing their products, and
viewing their videos can be very beneficial to a company. Many companies
provide spaces for comments and customer feedback on their websites. Receiving
this type of information from customers saves businesses a tremendous amount of
time and money, which would otherwise be spent on researching customer’s wants,
needs, and opinions (Bulut
& Mandaric, 2012 ).
Placing a video online also
gives businesses the opportunity to increase their awareness through
circulation of the video. Forty-two percent of web video viewers find videos
online by either clicking on an email link or using a search engine to track it
down (Rogers, 2007).
New media have so many roles in
the banking industries, not only the banking industry but in every
organization, which allows easy relationship between the customers to the
organization and the organization itself, it also help to facilitate the
productivity capacity of the organization. New media also have negative
influence as they have the positive ones. Computer crimes are becoming ever
prevalent in our society. As more and more companies and individuals rely on
services and resources provided through the internet and computers, computer
crimes such as cyber crime, electronic crimes, ATM Fraud, e-crimes-generally
refers to criminal activity where computer or network is the source, tool or
place of a crime are becoming everyday occurrence.
The new media, which use
websites, blogs, online videos, mobile devices as tools, have come to break
geographical barriers making the world a global village where information and
communication is shared with increased speed and volume. It has provided
opportunities for interactive communication that sparks up social rapid
changes.
How soon and well we embrace
the realities of these new media in Nigeria goes a long way in determining the
extent we experience these benefits. The approach of traditional media to the
new media will determine how true the realities we have at hand are showing a
replacement or not, the new media has come to improve the role of the
mainstream media (Omeruo,
2012).
NEW MEDIA AND THE MAGIC BULLET THEORY: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Theory building is one of the
goals of any intellectual discipline. Theory is a systematic and deductive way
of thinking about reality in order to describe and understand such reality (Daramola, 2001). Theories are the foundation
upon which predictions are made; it is a guide to action and aid in the
solution of problems.
Theoretical frameworks borrowed
from psychology, sociology, social anthropology, cultural anthropology and
economics are now found to be useful to commercial and academic research with
relations to the study of media effect (Adelola,
2006).
New media has presented
theoretical and analytical challenge to conventional theories of media and
society at every level of analysis. The social phenomenon associated with new
media, including the internet are only partially addressed by any of the
traditional theories of media effects, mass audiences, the political economy of
media, use and gratification, diffusion of innovations, critical/cultural/reception
theories (Lievrouw, 2002). Nevertheless,
this research study will attempt to explain the effect of the new media through
the “magic bullet theory of the media”
The theory is known by
different names. It is for instance called “bullet theory” (Schramm, 1971),
“the hypodermic-needle” (Berlo, 1960) and “stimulus-response” (Defleur &
Ball-Rokeach). The basic idea of the theory is that every member of the
audience receives media messages in a uniform way and that immediate and direct
response are triggered by such stimuli. The theory further assumes that there
is immediate response to media messages. In other words, the theory suggests
that people are vulnerable to media messages (Daramola,
2001). The theory simply
states that if people are exposed to a message, they will automatically comply.
All that the communication need to do was to get the audience to listen, and
the deed is done. The theory regarded the audience as passive and the mass
media as a supremely effective, mind-controlling agent.
But, as it turned out, this was
rather a simplistic assumption as the changes inspired through technological
advancement has led to the appreciation of the audience as highly active,
highly selective, manipulating rather than being manipulated by a message
(Daramola, I. 2001).
This groundswell’ has profoundly affected all
aspects of consumer behaviour, and has bestowed consumers with a power they
have not previously experienced in the marketplace (Li & Bernoff, 2008). In the new communications paradigm,
marketing managers should recognize the power and critical nature of the
discussions being carried out by consumers using new media.
In
the new communications paradigm, marketing
managers’ control over the content, timing and frequency of information is
severely being eroded. In the new paradigm, information about products and
services also originates in the marketplace. This information is based on the
experiences of individual consumers and is channelled through the traditional
promotion mix. However, various new media platforms, many of which are
completely independent of the producing/sponsoring organisation or its agents,
magnify consumers’ ability to communicate with one another (Bulut & Mandaric, 2012 ).
The above trends have severely
diminished the usefulness and practicality of the traditional communications
paradigm as a framework for developing marketing strategies. The new
communications paradigm, on the other hand, requires several important changes
in management ‘s attitudes and assumptions about…marketing strategy
formulation. First, marketing managers must accept the reality that a vast
amount of information about their products and services is being communicated
by individual consumers to other consumers via social media forums. Second,
consumers are responding to this information in ways that directly influence
all aspects of consumer behaviour, from information acquisition to the
post-purchase expressions of satisfaction and dissatisfaction. Third, consumers
are turning away from the traditional elements of the promotion mix; in
particular, they are reducing their reliance on advertising as a source of
information to guide their purchase decision-making. Finally, managers who are
accustomed to exerting a high level of control over company-to-consumer
messages must learn to talk with their customers, as opposed to talking at
them, therefore influencing the discussions taking place in the social media
space (Bulut & Mandaric, 2012 ).
The implication of this development is that organisations have to
rethink their overall marketing and promotional strategies. “Without taking
personal responsibility for your organisational brand on new media channels,
your ability to positively impact your organisation’s new media brand is likely
to be stunted”. Over the last one year, there have been improvements in the
adoption of new media by many organisations quite a number have set up new
media units and engaged a number of employees specifically for roles that
support their foray into new media customer relationship management. There has
been an increase in new media marketing spending as organisations try to outdo
one another in their race towards increasing share of mind on these channels (Uvie-Emegbo, 2013).
In the final analysis, we can
come to the conclusion that the new media has the potential to enlighten and
empower an individual. It also can be utilized to deprive citizens of their
privacy and fundamental liberties. In practice, individual empowerment is
subject to many conditions. First of all, individuals are likely to be
empowered only if they have an internal personal drive to achieve that end.
While the new media offers a surplus of up to date information, it has a
greater potential to hold corporate organisation accountable for their deeds
and keep them on their toes when it comes down customer relationship
management. It is therefore important for organisations to revisit …“the
Post-World war II effort to understand “the impact of the media on the society”
and use the knowledge to plan and design effective new media marketing
communication message (Folarin, 1998).
METHOD
OF STUDY
The survey research method was
adopted to answer the various research questions that arose as a result of the
study “…a method of collecting and analyzing social data via highly structured
and often very detailed interviews or questionnaires in order to obtain
information from large number of respondents presumed to be a representative of
a specific population” (Wiseman & Aron, 1970)
The study focused on First bank of Nigeria as case
study. The sample size comprises of one hundred and Thirty (130) customers of
the bank. A total of one hundred and Thirty questionnaires were administered. The
researcher utilized both primary and secondary data.
The questionnaire is divided
into two sections. Section A seeks to elicit responses on personal data of the
customers while the second part examines the opinion of the customers about the
marketing strategy of the bank. The general effect of the questionnaire is to
examine the impact of new media on the marketing strategies and performance of First
bank of Nigeria from which generalization will be made to other banks. Data
collected were analysed quantitatively using the
Chi square method of data analysis. The Chi square method provide
information…the richness of detail allows the researcher to understand the
results and thus derive more detailed information from this statistic than from
any other (McHugh, 2013). This data
analysis method was adopted because it is commonly used for testing relationships
on categorical variables (Statistics Solutions,
2016).
RESEARCH RELIABILITY
The Test - Retest method was used to
determine the reliability level. The instrument was administered twice within a
time interval of three weeks on the twenty customers selected during per
testing exercise. The data generated from the two administrations were also
correlated using Pearson Product moment correlations which yielded 0.91 co-
efficient of reliability. The instrument also yielded 0.78 cronbach alpha
indicating a high level of internal consistency of the instrument.
RESULT
HYPOTHESIS ONE
There is no significant relationship between consumers’
embrace of new media technology and its impact on the services rendered by First
Bank of Nigeria.
0
|
E
|
02
|
02 /E
|
28
|
30.72
|
784
|
25.5208333
|
2
|
2.88
|
4
|
1.388888888888889
|
18
|
14.4
|
324
|
22.5
|
22
|
21.76
|
484
|
22.24264705882353
|
2
|
2.04
|
4
|
1.96078431372549
|
10
|
10.2
|
100
|
9.803921568627451
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
12
|
10.24
|
144
|
14.0625
|
2
|
0.96
|
4
|
4.166666666666667
|
2
|
4.8
|
4
|
0.8333333333333333
|
2
|
1.28
|
4
|
3.125
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
105.6045751300654
|
TABLE 1: Sourced
from field Survey, 2013
X2=105.6045751300654-100
X2= 5.60457513006536
D.F. = (C-1) (R-1) = (3-1) (5-1)
=2*4=8
=:. X2 (alpha= 0.05, 8) = 15.507
The
alpha level of significance is 5 %( 0.05). Therefore, since X2
computed (5.60457513006536) is lesser than X2 tabulated (15.507),
i.e. lies in the acceptance region, we accept the H0 (There is a
significant difference in observed and expected data or frequencies).
HYPOTHESIS
TWO
There is no relationship between First Bank management’s
adoption of new media and the effective utilisation in its marketing strategies.
0
|
E
|
02
|
02 /E
|
32
|
33.28
|
1024
|
30.76923076923077
|
4
|
3.12
|
16
|
5.128205128205128
|
16
|
15.6
|
256
|
16.41025641025641
|
22
|
7.68
|
484
|
62.05128205128205
|
0
|
7.68
|
0
|
0
|
12
|
10.2
|
144
|
14.11764705882353
|
10
|
7.68
|
100
|
13.02083333333333
|
0
|
0.72
|
0
|
0
|
2
|
3.6
|
4
|
1.111111111111111
|
0
|
1.28
|
0
|
0
|
2
|
0.12
|
4
|
0.3333333333333333
|
0
|
0.6
|
0
|
0
|
142.9418991955757
|
TABLE 2: Sourced
from field Survey, 2013
X2 =142.9418991955757-100
X2 =42.94189919557566
D.F =
(C-1) (R-1) = (3-1) (5-1)
=2*4=8
X2
=
(alpha= 0.05, 8) = 15.507
Since
X2 computed (42.94189919557566) is greater than X2 tabulated (21.026),
i.e. lies in the rejection region, we reject the H0 (There is a
significant difference in observed and expected data or frequencies).
SUMMARY OF THE FINDINGS
·
There is no relationship
between consumers’ embrace of new media technology and its impact on services
rendered by First bank of Nigeria.
·
There
is partial relationship between First Bank’s management adoption of new media
and the effective utilisation in its marketing strategies.
DISCUSSION
Findings from the research
study revealed that the use of new media and social network is yet to take its
firm roots in the operations and promotion of Nigerian banks. This is indicated
by the statistics showing that, Facebook users dominate with 38%, Twitter 22%,
and YouTube 16%. This shows that majority the respondent use these social media
but they only come across First bank of Nigeria on Facebook.
Research Hypothesis One seeks
to validate the H0 that: “There is no significant relationship
between consumers’ embrace of new media technology and its impact on services
rendered by First Bank of Nigeria.” And at the alpha level of significance 5% (0.05), the H0
was accepted since X2 computed (5.60457513006536)
is lesser than X2 tabulated (15.507). Therefore, we can state that:
“There is no relationship between consumers’ embrace of
new media technology and its impact on the services rendered by First Bank of
Nigeria.”
Research Hypothesis Two seeks
to test the H0 which states that:
“There is no relationship between First
Bank management’s adoption of new media and the effective utilisation in its
marketing strategies.” Since X2 computed (42.94189919557566) is
greater than X2 tabulated (21.026), therefore the H0 was
rejected. Consequently, it is safe to state that “there is a partial relationship between First Bank’s
management adoption of new media and the effective utilisation in its marketing
strategies.”
Based on
the findings from this research, it was discovered that today’s organisations
are confronted with rapidly changing market conditions, indicated by high
investment rates, strong competitors and the proliferation of constantly
changing media. Under these conditions, traditional management approaches that
focus on financial figures and centralised analytical planning methods are
considered to be insufficient for effectively steering the organisations in a
dynamical environment (Hoffmann, 2002).
The following recommendations will be made based on the findings of the
research work:
The rapid growth of internet, online social networks
and ubiquity of mobile phones in much of the world offers marketers enormous
potential for engaging consumers in radically new ways. The nature of these new
communication platforms differs from traditional media in important ways that
can make them more effective for marketing, most notably the potential for
deeper consumer engagement, multi-directional information exchange, and
location-based tracking and messaging.
However, using digital media to
build a boundary-less bank will require a pragmatic approach. Customers’ need
to save, spend and transfer money in a secure environment remains unchanged,
but their behaviours are changing radically. Before they set foot in a branch,
customers are increasingly comfortable using the Internet to seek advice and
gather product and service information. They expect to be able to choose the
channel most convenient for them, whether that’s a branch office, browsing the
bank’s website or using a video enhanced call center and they insist that all
channels work together harmoniously. They expect all of the companies they do
business with (and particularly their banks) to know them as individuals,
anticipate their needs and actively involve them in coming up with tailored
solutions (Vater, Cho, & Sidebottom, 2012).
It is therefore recommended that Nigerian Banks should take a wholistic and
personalised approach to the new media marketing in order to cater for the
individual and collective needs of its customers.
Secondly,
technology by itself will not deliver a competitive advantage. What banks do
with it to develop a unique, personalised customer experience will matter most
of all. Success will take much more than a string of initiatives that utilises
“high-tech” gadgetry and “cool” applications in a traditional banking
infrastructure and mindset. Indeed, technology for its own sake is a costly
distraction, which adds complexity, muddies decision making and impedes the
organisations’ ability to adapt and function effectively in a highly
competitive environment. Failure to take a disciplined approach will divert
attention from the pressing need to break through the conventional walls of
retail banking-both literal and cultural-and engage customers seamlessly across
all channels, on their own terms (Vater, Cho,
& Sidebottom, 2012).
Over the last one year, there
have been improvements in the adoption of new media by many organisations.
Quite a number have set up new media units and engage a number of employees
specifically for the roles that support their foray into new media engagement.
There has also been an increase in new media marketing spending as
organisations try to outdo one another in their race towards increasing share
of mind on these channels.
If Nigerian Banks do not take personal
responsibility for their brand on new media channels, their ability to
positively impact the organisation’s new media brand is likely to be stunted.
That is if personnel’s knowledge, skills, experience around new media is
limited, then they are unlikely to be able to help the organistion get the most
out of its new media effort (Uvie-Emegbo, 2013).
It is not enough for Nigerian
banks to “pay lip service” to new media marketing strategies and activities
such as Cashless banking, mobile banking, online banking, 24 hours banking
without streamlining the various customer engagement channels into a seamless
financial service delivery that will satisfy both the banks and its customers.
This is only achievable through committed, focused and conscious effort that is
devoid of any form of financial “propaganda.”
REFERENCES
Adegbaju, A., & Olokoyo, F.
(2008). Recapitalisation and Banks’ Performance:
A Case Study of Nigerian Banks. African
Economic and Business Review Vol. 6 No. 1. , 10.
Adelola, A. (2006, December). An Evaluation of the Impact of International
Advertising on Local Societies. Olabisi
Onabanjo University-Project document . Ago-Iwoye, Ogun State, Nigeria:
Unpublished work.
Adepoju, T. (2003). Mass Communication
Research: An Introduction. Ibadan: Sceptre Print Ltd.
Agboola, A., & Ologunde, O.
(2009). Digital Marketing Versus New Media Marketing. Journal of Electronic Commerce.
, Volume 7, Issue 4:.
Alkali, T., Alu, F., Tarnong, M.,
& Ogbu., E. (2013). The Impact of Social Marketing Networks on the Promotion
Of Nigerian Global Market: An Analytical Approach. www.ijhssi.org ,
Volume 2 Issue 3.
Argenti, P., & Barnes, C. (2009).
Digital Strategies for Powerful Communications. New York: McGraw Hill.
Belch, G., & Belch, M. (2004). Advertising
and promotion; An integrated Marketing Communication Perspective. Newyork:
McGraw Hill.
Bulut, I., & Mandaric, M. (2012
). Researching the Role of Social Media Marketing in Contemporary Business Practices.
Russia: Symorg 2012 , 87-92.
Chile, C. (2012). Marketing
Foundations for Advertising and Public Relations. Dinpet: Media Group.
Ciacu, N. (2011). The Impact of New Media
on Society. Univeristatea “Constantin Brâncoveanu” Piteşti.
Cochin. (2000). Marketing Strategies
of the Banking Industry. India: Beehive digital concept for Mahatma Ghandi
University.
Dahlström, P., & Edelman, D.
(2013). The Coming Era of ‘On-demand’ Marketing.
McKinsey Quarterly , 5.
Daramola, I. (2001). Introduction
to Mass Communication. . Lagos: Rothan Press limited.
Ekeanyanwu, N., Onwubere, C., &
Ofulue, C. (2012). Data Analysis in Communication Research. Lagos:
Unpublished lecture note developed for the National Open University of Nigeria
(NOUN).
Flew, T. (2002). New Media: An
Introduction. Cambridge: Oxford University Press.
Folarin, B. (1998). Theories of
Mass Communication: An Introductory Text. Ibadan: Sterlin-Horden
Publishers.
Fulk, J., & DeSanctis, G. (1995).
Electronic Communication and Changing Organisational Forms. Organisational
Science. Emerging Media: Prevalence and Impact in the Work Place.
Gephart, R. (2004). Sensemaking and New
Media at Work. American Behavioral Scientist.
Hennig-Thurau, T., Malthouse, E., C.,
F., Gensler, S., Lobschat, L., Rangaswamy, A., et al. (2010, August 10). The
Impact of New Media on Customer. Retrieved July 6, 2013, from
http://www.sagepublications.com: http://jsr.sagepub.com/content/13/3/311
Hoffmann, O. (2002). Performance
Management-System and Implementation Strategy. Berlin: Haupt publishers co.
Jablin, F., & Putnam, L. The
New Handbook of Organisational Communication. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Jordaan, M. (2012, July 15). Banking
on Social Media; The Secret to FNB’s Success./. Retrieved August 18, 2013,
from www.fnb.co.za: www.fnb.co.za
Kalejaiye. (2001). Introductiom to Communication Research. Olabisi Onabanjo University lecture note
(p. 10). Ago Iwoye: Mass communication department.
KPMG. (2013, June). 2013 Banking
Industry Customer Satisfaction Survey. Retrieved October 31, 2013, from
kpmg.com/ng: www.kpmg.com/ng
Li, C., & Bernoff, J. (2008). Groundswell:
Winning in a World Transformed By Social Technologies. Boston: Harvard
Business Press.
Lievrouw, L. (2002). Theorising New
Media. Medien Journal , 4-13.
Monnier, P. (1999). Cybermarketing;
A Guide for Managers in Developing Countries. Geneva: Technical Paper.
McHugh, M. (2013, February 23). The Chi-square Test of
Independence. Retrieved from PubMed:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/23894860/
Naughton, J. (2006). Blogging and
the Emerging Media Ecosystem. United kingdom: University of Oxford.
Olujide, J., & Aremu, M. (2009).
A Comparative Analysis of Strategic Marketing Planning Adoption in Nigerian
Banking and Insurance Industry. African Research Review, An International
Multi-Disciplinary Journal. , 182-198.
Oluwagbemi, O., Abah, J., &
Achimugu, P. (2011). The Impact of Information Technology in Nigerian Banking
industry. A Journal of Computer Science and Engineering, , Volume 7,
Issue 2.
Omeruo, K. (2012). E-Merging
Media; Challenges for Traditional Media in Nigeria. Retrieved July 21,
2013, from www.techtrendsng.com: www.techtrendsng.com
Peltier, J., Schibrowsky, J., &
Schultz, D. (2003). Interactive Integrated Marketing Communication: Combining
the Power of IMC, The New Media and Database Marketing. International
Journal of Advertising , 93–115.
Polk Center for Automotive Studies.
(2013, January 31). PR Newswire. Retrieved July 06, 2013, from
www.prNewswire.com: http://www.prNewswire.com
PWC. (2010, May). When the Growing
Gets Tough: How Retail Banks Can Thrive in a Disruptive, Mobile, Regulated World.
A publication of PwC’s Financial Services Institute (FSI) , pp. 1-46.
Ramanujam, R. (2008 ). Mass Communication
and Its Digital Transformation. New Delhi: APH Publication Corporation.
Rice, R., & Gattiker, U. (2001).
New Media and Organisation Structuring. In Jablin, F & Putnam, L. (The New
Handbook of Organisational Communication (pp. 544-581). Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage.
Rogers, Z. (2007, July 21). The Myth
of Pre-Roll Video Ad Scarcity. Retrieved June 1, 2013, from
http://www.clickz.com: (http://www.clickz.com/showPage.html?page=3625816).
Statistics
Solutions. (2016). StatisticsSolutions. Retrieved from StatisticsSolutions;
Advancement through clarity:
www.statisticssolutions.com/using-chi-square-statistic-in-research/
Taiwo, R. (2010). The Thumb Tribe:
Creativity and Social Change Through SMS in Nigeria. California Linguistic
Notes , Volume XXXV No. 1.
Uvie-Emegbo, A. (2013, September 4).
Taking New Media Seriously. The Punch Newspaper . Nigeria: The Punch
Newspaper.
Vater, D., Cho, Y., & Sidebottom,
P. (2012). The Digital Challenge to Retail Banks. . U.S.A: Bain &
Company, Inc.
Webopedia. (2008, Octobe 1). Webopedia.
Retrieved Juiy 21, 2013, from Webopedia:
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/N/new_media.html.
Wikipedia. (2013, July 5). Http://en.wikipedia.com/new_media//.
Retrieved August 10, 2013, from Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.,:
Http://en.wikipedia.com.
Wilson, D., Esiri, M., &
Onwubere, C. (2008). JLS 714: Communication Research. Lagos: Unpublished
Lecture Note developed for the National Open University of Nigeria (NOUN).
Wiseman, J., & Aron, M. (1970). Field
Projects for Sociology Students. Cambridge: M.A: Schenkman.
Wright, D., & Hinson, M. (2011).
A Three-Year Longitudinal Analysis of Social and Emerging Media Use in Public
Relations Practice. Public Relations Journal Vol. 5, No. 3 , 1-32.
www.15projects.com (n.d.). www.15projects.com.
Retrieved June 3, 2013
www.StudyMode.com (2009, May 03). Retention
Strategies in Post Consolidation Banking Industry in Nigeria; A Case Study of
First Bank Nigeria Plc). Retrieved from http://www.studymode.com/essays/Retention-Strategies-In-Post-Consolidation-Banking-194378.:
http://www.studymode.com/essays/Retention-Strategies-In-Post-Consolidation-Banking-194378.
Xiang, Z., & Gretzel, U. (2010). Role
of Social Media in Online Travel Information Search, Tourism Management.
Copyright: ©2016 Adelola aderogbayimika Adeyemi
ReplyDeleteBE SMART AND BECOME RICH IN LESS THAN 3DAYS...It all depends on how fast you can be to get the new PROGRAMMED blank ATM card that is capable of hacking into any ATM machine, anywhere in the world. I got to know about this BLANK ATM CARD when I was searching for job online about a month ago..It has really changed my life for good and now I can say I'm rich and I can never be poor again. The least money I get in a day with it is about $5000. Everyday I keeping pumping money into my account. there is no risk of being caught , because it has been programmed in such a way that it is not traceable, it also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTVs to detect you..For details on how to get yours today, email the hackers on: andersonhackers22@gmail.com and tell your loves one's too.